Discovering McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club: A Northwoods Culinary Tradition
Nestled in the heart of Wisconsin's scenic Northwoods, McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club, located at 1506 Jerry Rd, St Germain, WI 54558, United States, stands as a cherished institution. More than just a place to dine, it represents a continuation of a cherished regional culinary heritage—the classic supper club experience. For generations, this establishment has served as a gathering point for locals and visitors alike, offering a warm, inviting atmosphere coupled with time-honored dining traditions. The very name, "Blink Bonnie," evokes a sense of timeless charm and genuine hospitality that permeates every corner of the venue. Stepping across the threshold is akin to stepping back into an era where quality service and hearty, well-prepared meals were the cornerstones of a memorable evening out. It’s a place where conversations flow easily, the lighting is just right, and the focus remains squarely on the enjoyment of good food and good company.
The supper club concept itself is deeply ingrained in the culture of Wisconsin, emphasizing a relaxed pace, perhaps starting with a classic cocktail, moving through a relish tray, and culminating in a substantial main course. McGregor's honors this tradition while subtly adapting to contemporary tastes, ensuring that while the spirit remains authentic, the offerings are always fresh and appealing. The setting, surrounded by the natural beauty of St. Germain, adds an undeniable layer of appeal, making a visit here a perfect complement to any outdoor adventure or quiet retreat in the area. It is this dedication to tradition, quality ingredients, and an unwavering commitment to the guest experience that has cemented McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club's reputation as a must-visit destination in Northern Wisconsin.
What truly sets McGregor's apart in a landscape dotted with dining options is its steadfast commitment to delivering that quintessential Northwoods dining experience. It’s an environment crafted for lingering, for savoring each course, and for creating lasting memories. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance: sophisticated enough for a special occasion, yet comfortable enough for a casual weeknight dinner. This accessibility, combined with culinary excellence, forms the bedrock of its enduring popularity. Whether you are a long-time resident familiar with every nuance of the menu or a first-time visitor drawn by reputation, the welcome at 1506 Jerry Rd is consistently warm and genuine.
Key Highlights of the McGregor's Dining Experience
McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club distinguishes itself through several defining characteristics that contribute to its beloved status. These elements combine to create an experience that is both familiar and exceptional:
The Authentic Supper Club Ambiance: The club meticulously preserves the classic Wisconsin supper club atmosphere. This includes the dimly lit dining rooms, the comfortable seating arrangements conducive to conversation, and the overall sense of relaxed formality. It’s an environment where patrons feel encouraged to unwind and enjoy the full dining ritual, from appetizers to after-dinner drinks. This dedication to atmosphere is a significant draw for those seeking a genuine taste of regional dining history.
Commitment to Quality Preparation: While specific menu details are best discovered in person, the establishment is renowned for its focus on high-quality ingredients prepared with care. The culinary approach respects classic preparations while ensuring that every dish served meets a high standard of flavor and presentation. This consistency in quality is crucial for maintaining the trust and loyalty of its diverse clientele over the years.
A Strong Sense of Community Connection: More than a commercial venture, McGregor's functions as a vital social hub for the St. Germain community and the surrounding Northwoods area. It serves as a reliable backdrop for celebrations, reunions, and routine gatherings. This deep integration into the local social fabric lends an authenticity that cannot be manufactured, making every visit feel like a return to a familiar, welcoming place.
The Northwoods Setting: Situated in St. Germain, the restaurant benefits immensely from its location. The surrounding environment of lakes, forests, and natural tranquility enhances the dining experience, offering a peaceful escape from the hustle of city life. The journey to 1506 Jerry Rd is often part of the pleasure, setting the stage for a relaxing and restorative meal.
These pillars—atmosphere, quality, community, and setting—are interwoven, creating a dining destination that offers far more than just sustenance. They offer an experience rooted in tradition and delivered with genuine care.
Concluding Thoughts on a Northwoods Gem
McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club is an essential stop for anyone wishing to understand the culinary soul of Northern Wisconsin. It successfully bridges the gap between cherished tradition and contemporary dining expectations. The dedication evident in the service, the quality of the food, and the preservation of the classic supper club ethos ensures that a visit here is always meaningful. For those seeking an evening characterized by warmth, excellent food, and the unique charm of the Northwoods, McGregor's at 1506 Jerry Rd remains a distinguished and highly recommended destination. It is a place where every guest is treated like a valued regular, reinforcing its status as a true local treasure.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Dinner
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Spirits
Wine
Dining options
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar on site
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Historic
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Usually a wait
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Menus
Photos
Reviews Mcgregors Blink Bonnie Supper Club
Brad “Butch” Colburn
29-05-2026
Loved the place! It gets a little meat smokey when a bunch of steaks are served, but what a great smell! Good Brandy old fashion's! Shrimp and scallops wee good, Mare enjoyed her burger too!
Paul DeBoer
18-05-2026
Awesome filet mignon, hash browns, salad, bread and SoCo Old-fashioned. The filet was cooked to perfection... very tender and tasty. We were lucky to have only a short wait. I highly recommend McGregor's Blink Bonnie. I have been going here for 50+ years and they never disappoints me. More
John McKevitt
15-05-2026
I proposed to my wife here 40 years today. Today is our anniversary although she passed away 24 years ago. I thought it would be nice to have dinner back where it all started. The war axes at the hostess stand thought otherwise. It’s Friday … More
Jeff Snapp
21-04-2026
I think my expectations were too high. The tailgating before 4:00 was fun. The service was great. I enjoyed the salad and hash browns more than the steak. It was cooked perfectly but didn't have any flavor and was very tough. The scallops were okay.
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 3
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Moderate noise
Group size
2 people
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Taylor Pipes
06-04-2026
Wow. Zers. I’ve had my fair share of Wisconsin steaks like the really good one in Madison named after a Midwestern weather phenomenon, but this place hit at another level.
We went on a Friday night and that turned out to be a great move. While the hordes were waiting hours for supper club and tavern fish fry, we were able to scoot into two bar seats while we waited about 35 minutes for a dining room table.
This place does one thing exceptionally well — steak. I ordered the NY Strip and my wife got the filet. It came out searing flippin’ hot and was a production in of itself. Mine was cooked perfect (medium rare) and served with a salad and potato. I opted for hash browns smothered in cheese and since I love steakhouses with steak toppings — I was delighted to get grilled mushrooms and onions on my Strip.
A top five all~time steak for me. I cannot wait to get back here.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
sandra
05-04-2026
Pretty small and a first come first serve, no reservations. There is usually a line to get in, so it's best to get there early, but either way you'll be waiting for at minimum 30 - 40 min. If you don't get seated in the first round you get put on the waiting list and wait time can be about 40 minutes to a hour. Their specialty steak is very good, but from the others with us that had something other than that, said it lacked flavor and chicken was kind of dry. Staff was very nice and move fast. Their was a large group of us and they were very accommodating. That is also why this review lacks photos. For the price tho I think the sides should be bigger. There is also parking on both sides of the building and in front
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Group size
1 person, 2 people, 3-4 people
Wait time
1+ hour
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Bar area
nevaeh borchardt
05-04-2026
I was so dissatisfied with the service here that I created a google account to give this review. I would like to start off with the fact that I waited an hour and a half for a table. The atmosphere is so horrid, I could barely breathe … More
Herb Hammons
12-03-2026
Two people had the chicken that couldn’t even be cut with a steak knife it was so bad and overcooked. mentioned it to the waitress they were going to bring two new entrées. We waited and waited and waited. Finally, we told him not to … More
Lisa Baxter
02-03-2026
What a unique place ! We arrived at 3 pm , the line gets long fast and they open at 4 pm. Awesome salad with house dressing ( everyone in line suggested it ) so good ! Also a little warm loaf of bread to share . We both had steak , lobster … More
Darcy Maxwell
19-02-2026
This supper club deserves every single rave review that it receives. From the old fashioneds to the salads and then the steaks - perfection! Expect to wait, but know that it’s worth it. Highly recommend the stop when you’re in the Northwoods!
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Filet Mignon and Scallops, Fresh Hot Bread, House Salad Bowl, Steak and Lobster
Wait time
1+ hour
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Bar area, Outdoor patio / terrace
Parking options
Free parking lot
Jason Buretta
17-02-2026
We arrived 20 minutes after they opened and there was already a 90 minute wait. Just shows how popular this place is. … More
Janeen Thompson
14-02-2026
The menu says steak medium rare is a warm red center. All four of us ordered medium rare. It came on a hot sizzling plate which must have kept the steak cooking. We all felt our steaks were overcooked. We ordered 2 ribeyes, one 7 oz … More
Teresa Protasio
23-01-2026
This place is so worth it! Even if you have to wait a while. The food is phenomenal! The staff extremely friendly and attentive. And the drinks are 👌👌 you have to try the manhattan! And for food you cannot go without trying the steak and seafood!! Highly recommend it!! … More
Mark D
18-01-2026
Been a while, I used to go there pretty regularly on vacation about 30 years ago, and was hoping it still maintained it's charm. It did not disappoint, the food was excellent, and the service was great. The prices are on par or below the … More
A S
31-12-2025
Blink Bonnie is a small restaurant but the food is amazing! The filet mignon comes out still sizzling and is so tender. The bartender and wait staff are wonderful. You need to get there early but it's worth the wait! More
Eric Walk
29-11-2025
McGregor's is a quintessential North Woods experience.
EXPECT TO WAIT.
Their wee kitchen can only turn out so much at a time, and I noticed one stove is dedicated to heating the sizzling platters your steaks come out on.
That, in conjunction with 13 tables, limits the turnover.
Having said that, the drinks are well poured, the staff is friendly, the food is great, and the people watching more than makes up for no TV to stare at in the bar.
They are also installing a new patio area, not to eat on, but to make your wait more enjoyable ( see 'people watching' comment above).
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Garrett Paul
26-11-2025
Stopped in during the Tomahawk Fall Ride and had a 12oz Ribeye + scallops. The long wait was expected, they were packed. Food was outstanding.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Kelly Shaver
17-11-2025
This place is UH.MAZE.ING. Warning: you will more than likely have to wait a long time -- this place is teeny-tiny -- and it is kinda pricey -- BUT the food is phenom. Their steaks are SO GOOD! I always get mushrooms on mine -- but be … More
Lindsey Miller
15-11-2025
The draw of McGregor’s is the tradition, experience, and service. If you’re going to line up before open bring your tailgate accessories (chair and drinks) and be prepared for the earliest arrivals to have sent a designated representative … More
Joshua N
30-10-2025
I wanted to love this place. The atmosphere is exactly what you want for a WI supper club! Four of us stopped in after a round of golf across the street. Drinks & service were great. The real problem was the cook on our steaks. We all ordered med rare. They were all hockey pucks unfortunately. For the price and wait time we were very disappointed in this.
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 3
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
jason puls
10-10-2025
Definitely one of the best ribeye steaks I've had ever! So tender and buttery was unbelievable. 2 hour wait and very crowded but worth it. Will go back when up north!
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Group size
3-4 people
Wait time
1+ hour
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Bar area
Hank Johnson
05-10-2025
Blink Bonnie’s = a North Woods go to spot.
What to know:
No reservations- average wait 1-2 hours ( bring games, hang out on picnic tables … More
Pam Tippel
05-10-2025
Be prepared to wait...only 11 tables available. They open at 4pm and people wait in line before hand. No reservations accepted. Once your name is on list, you can wait at bar or wait outside. People bring their lawn chairs and coolers … More
Mike Sherkey
27-09-2025
Haven't been here in 20 years, and it is still as great as it was back then. Got the 7 oz filet with grilled oinions, and it melts in your mouth. The salad is great, too. Got there at 4 PM when they opened and had to wait for a table 1.5 hours. Our server Haylee was outstanding. Highly recommend this place. More
Mariann Tomaro
25-08-2025
Had excellent dinners of the most delicious Sizzling Ribeye Steaks with friends celebrating both of our 39th & 40th Wedding Anniversaries. A Wonderful family owned Supper Club who treated us as family. Our long time experienced server was … More
Kristopher Woppert
26-06-2025
I went once when I was a kid. Since then I have tried about 50 times, no joke, to go back. Never been able to. Even went at 3pm and still had a 2 hour wait. Went at 5pm and they said 7:30 at the earliest. Love the food just not the wait. Honestly, it’s not even that special for the amount of hype and wait. More
joseph hein
13-06-2025
There is not a better place in the northwoods! The hostess is absolutely the best! Her smiling face and her personality is so charismatic , warm and welcoming! Waitresses are tops along with the bartender! Food and atmosphere is second to done! Been coming here for 40 years and never had a bad meal❤️
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Wait time
1+ hour
Seating type
Indoor dining area
Susan
31-05-2025
I was so disappointed with Blink Bonnies as we had heard it was so good. Honestly, it was not very good. I could not believe the high prices, small portions and extra charges for everything. Clearly they are exploiting the tourists on … More
Nicole Supan
05-05-2025
This was my first time here. My husband has gone before while he was up north snowmobiling. Yes the wait is long but the food and service is top notch. We got to know the owner and the story behind the restaurant. Had my first Wisconsin Old … More
Dan A
02-05-2025
Great place. Everyone says get there before it opens. I disagree. We got there about a half hour after they opened. Had a 2 hour wait. Place was packed. We got seats at the bar and went on to have one of my favorite WI supper club experiences as we had an old fashioned or three and met some wonderful people. I was actually a little disappointed when our table was ready. Great place.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reviews Mcgregors Blink Bonnie Supper Club